Sunday, February 24, 2013

The Lofgies: If I Owned the Oscars

This was going to be a massive entry with nominations for all categories, but it turns out I just don't have the time for that. So, instead, feast your eyes on my top ten films of 2012. If I owned the Oscars, and the entire Academy consisted of me, these would be the ten films nominated for Best Picture. So, in alphabetical order, I present the Lofgy nominees!


I have to admit - was surprised when this one took the Golden Globe. And now it's a likely Oscar Best Picture winner? I thought it was pretty good, but best picture good? Eh. Admittedly, I did love the opening scene. It did a great job of sucking me immediately into the story, creating excellent tension and a feeling of authenticity. Unfortunately, the writing wasn't always able to sustain those qualities, inserting cheap Hollywood ploys instead of trusting the fascinating true details of the story. Characters weren't developed much, but the directing was capable and the story absorbing.

Beasts of the Southern Wild

It helps if you approach this not as a movie, but as a visual form of poetry, an emotional character study that builds its own world in the territory of magical realism. To fully appreciate Beasts of the Southern Wild, you have to set aside your adult eyes and let the movie bring you into a child's mind. Everyone will get something different out of it and it's not the kind of film everyone is going to love. Look at it too closely and some of the pieces might start to peel apart. But, it is the kind of film that everyone will remember. And, the leading performance is astounding for its rawness and truth.

Cabin in the Woods

I know, I know. Hah, hah, hah. A horror film? Nominated for an Oscar? Okay, well it's happened a couple of times, but not many. However, I do have the power to nominate it for a Lofgy. Why? If you've seen it, you know. If you haven't seen it... well... it's an intelligent deconstruction of the horror genre that actually addresses a lot of the conflicting emotions and thoughts I personally have in regards to horror.  Things happen in this movie that you've definitely never seen before. Cabin in the Woods turns audiences' expectations upside down and inside out, all the while managing to subscribe to and subvert a traditional, three-act structure. Plus, it's funny. So, if you can handle a little gore, you should check it out. It might change the way you think about scary movies.

Django Unchained

The remarkable thing about this film? Hmm... well, there's the thoughtful and effective pacing. There's the cast filled with vibrant characters who wear their roles like well-fitting, yet beautifully embroidered jackets. Oh, and also the dialogue that sparks and crackles, squeezing laughs out of the audience. It's fun and occasionally rises above the simple adventure/exploitation flick it pretends to be - offering the viewer a candy-coated challenge. I think Tarantino has more crayons in his box than the rest of us. There were a couple elements that didn't sit well with me, (won't elaborate for fear of spoilling) but, in fairness, it wouldn't be a Tarantino picture without these things. This one is larger than life, folks.


When Lincoln started, I became concerned that it might turn out to be an ongoing pastiche of triumphant music, triumphant speeches and small children staring up in adoration at the important man. Fortunately, it wasn't. In its strongest moments, Lincoln steps away from the biopic format and immerses itself in the very real, very complex frustrations of pushing, and sometimes even shoving, a country forward. It boasts a large cast of characters with conflicting motives, many of whom are an absolute joy to watch. A few of the more personal aspects of Lincoln's life, family members and such, are given short shrift, however, by the time the music finally does soar, the viewer feels the kind of emotion that comes from more than just cheap pandering.


It's a shame that this film was probably never even considered for a nomination. It demonstrates so much creativity that it nearly knocked me over, but also balances all the raw imagination with moments of solemnity and scenes where even the most jaded viewer might find new nightmares to follow them into the morning. Though it did annoy me a bit that so many plot points were explained away with "Well, that's how it is in the future", the film was entertaining, unpredictable and added up to a surprisingly emotional experience. More of this, please.

The Master

At the center of this film is the relationship between two extremely different men, one desperate for a saviour and the other trying to be that saviour. The ways in which they connect, strive and delude themselves are fascinating. The movie is most famous for being a thinly veiled expose on Scientology, but that isn't all it has to share. The imagery is lovely, the structure untraditional, the acting powerful, and the writing dares to wander into challenging and complex territory. An excellent film.

Moonrise Kingdom

Possibly the most Wes Andersony of Wes Anderson films, Moonrise Kingdom proves that Wes Andersoniness can be a glorious thing. Filled with thoughtful details, the heart of this story is about all the ways children and adults face the loneliness and small cruelties of life. Music? Literature? Maybe an affair or even an island campground far away. Those of us who are most fortunate can find understanding in another human and the most beautiful moments in this movie are the moments where the characters truly connect, reaching through all the fantasy and the kitsch to approach something real and ultimately human.

Searching for Sugar Man

This documentary is a more recent addition to the list, since I didn't get to see it in the theaters. It also bumped the excellent French film, Rust and Bone, off the list. What is Searching for Sugar Man? It's the story of Rodriguez, a poet and singer living in Detroit. Though extremely talented, when Rodriguez released a couple of albums in the early 70s, he got completely passed over. The albums didn't sell and Rodriguez went back to working in construction, his talent supposedly silenced. Yet, all the while, he was gaining tremendous popularity in South Africa. Though no one there knew anything about him, his songs spoke to those suffering beneath the oppressive South African government and he became, according to many in the country, as big as the Beatles. The film is punctuated by and ultimately successful because of Rodriguez's haunting music, which is woven throughout. I loved this movie. Even if you think no one cares, you should still sing. You never know. Even if you never find out, your song could be the exact thing someone needs.

Zero Dark Thirty

An immersing examination of the manhunt for Osama Bin Laden. This film has been controversial and, given the topics within, that was probably unavoidable. In my opinion, Zero Dark Thirty is balanced in its exploration of how torture was utilized during this time. It presents information and allows the viewer to come to their own conclusions regarding morality vs. effectiveness. What else does it do well? It manages to build tension within a story where the viewer already knows the outcome. It makes the mundane fascinating and the fascinating mundane, but, that of course makes it fascinating again... Best of all? It captures the complexity of emotions surrounding the entire ordeal, the way it makes us face who we have become as a country and question how these events define us. So yeah. In my opinion, it's a very good movie.

There you have it! My top ten of the year. However, I'm horrible at picking favorites, so I don't know which one I actually liked best. What do you think? Who should take the grand prize? Let me know your thoughts on any of these films and feel free to post your own favorites of 2012 below. Yay movies!


  1. Always look forward to your Oscar analysis/predictions Sarah. We're heading to our annual Oscar viewing party soon, so this was also very timely! :-)

    Of your list, I haven't seen Argo or Lincoln. I agree with you completely on 'Beasts' ... it's poetry, and not everyone will get it. I especially agree with what you said about it holding up to close scrutiny--many people are just going to write it off as weird.

    Django is my personal favorite of the ones that are actually nominated for best picture. Just loved that movie for it's pure entertainment value. It IS very Tarantino, but I feel it's the best he's ever done. (And I'm a huge fan of Inglorious and Kill Bill.)

    Zero Dark deserves recognition, but I think Chastaine's performance is what really stood out for me in that film. She was outstanding--a character I'd love to write. :-)

    My favorite movie, overall, from last year is Moonrise Kingdom. Just brilliant on many levels. It's one of those movies, again as a writer, I say, "That's what I'd like to create."

    Should be a fun and unpredictable night!

    1. Yay! Hope you have a great time at the party. Moonrise Kingdom was probably my favorite film of the year as well. It hit all the right notes in new and interesting ways.

      I agree with you regarding Chastaine's performance. Very strong. I won't hate it if Jennifer Lawrence wins, because she was great, but I'm rooting for Chastaine.

      Lincoln was great and I'd like to see it beat Argo (since it's probably between the two of them for best picture). It's a more complete film.

  2. I have been pathetic about seeing films this year, so I am definitely not in a position to create my own awards. Your list seems like a great starting place for picking up some good rentals though! And I've read some interesting summaries/critiques of Cabin in the Woods (because I love reading horror but hating watching it!) so I can see why you'd include it - I love works that take genre conventions and turn them on their heads or expose them as part of the story.

    1. Cabin in the Woods definitely turns the genre's convention on its head. I'm more likely to read horror as well, but I liked this film a lot. It is fairly violent, but it uses the violence to excellent effect.

  3. Touching base. I guess you're taking a break.

    1. It's hard to find the time and motivation with work, but I'm trying to be better about it. Thanks for stopping by!